Hysterical Scientism by Marilynne Robinson, originally published in Harper's.
I don't believe in Richard Dawkins by Kenan Malik in The Telegraph
(via Comments by Mark Adams and by Kate at Open Book)
Update: Two more reviews:
Beyond Belief by Jim Holt in The New York Times, October 22, 2006
Lunging, Flailing, Mispunching by Terry Eagleton, London Review of Books, October 19, 2006
(via Grant Gallicho at dotCommonweal)