The performance was based on Guerrero's selection of music for the Feast of the Assumption, circa 1575. (Very prescient if the Assumption was something Pope Pius XII pulled out of his tiara in 1950). Can't fault the composer. Guerrero's music was in use for two centuries after his death. Can't fault the esthetics of the venue, Luther Memorial Church. Can't fault the able performers. Something seemed not quite right; maybe it was the lack of the Mass itself. Or maybe it was listening to liturgical music on a full stomach.
The authorized Old Rite sung masses (11:30 AM, Mary Help of Christians Church) also uses old polyphonic settings.
ReplyDeleteNone by Guerrero. However, Vittoria was a near-contemporary and they use his stuff.
Also some early German, as well as good ol' Palestrina.
And yes, hearing the Ordinary without the Mass is not...quite...right.